A Denver Catholic priest known for preaching on sin, repentance, confession, and traditional Church teachings is preparing to leave his parish following months of controversy and complaints from parishioners. The decision comes just weeks after Archbishop James Golka imposed restrictions on the public speaking ministry of prominent Catholic exorcist Father Ripperger, raising new questions about the archbishop’s recent decisions involving traditionally minded Catholic clergy.
Father Daniel Ciucci, pastor of Most Precious Blood Catholic Church in Denver, announced that he will begin a roughly six-month sabbatical after Christmas at the request of Archbishop James Golka. The priest is expected to remain away from parish ministry until July 2027, after which he may receive an assignment at another parish.
The decision follows a petition signed by hundreds of people raising concerns about Ciucci’s leadership, as well as criticism from parishioners who objected to his preaching on difficult moral and spiritual subjects.
According to LifeSiteNews and reporting by The Denver Post, the controversy has raised questions about parish leadership, the responsibilities of Catholic priests, and how the Church should respond when its teachings become a source of division.
Priest Addresses Departure and Calls for Unity
In a video message shared with parishioners, Father Ciucci described his upcoming sabbatical as an opportunity for spiritual renewal, prayer, and reflection on his priesthood.
Rather than publicly criticizing Archbishop Golka, Ciucci expressed gratitude for the opportunity to step away from his responsibilities.
“The archbishop met me in this place of tenderness, and it opened both to me and to him the fact that I’ve been carrying a pain with me for some time here,” Ciucci explained.
He described the archbishop’s decision as an expression of concern for both the parish and its pastor.
The priest also acknowledged the challenges clergy sometimes face when presenting Catholic teachings that conflict with contemporary cultural attitudes.
In his farewell message, Ciucci specifically referenced Church teachings concerning contraception, marriage between one man and one woman, the Eucharist, confession, and humanity’s need for God’s mercy.
These teachings remain established elements of Catholic doctrine, even when they provoke disagreement among members of a parish community.
Despite the controversy, Ciucci encouraged those who supported him to welcome his successor and avoid allowing disagreements to create further division.
“I hold no animosity toward anyone,” he said.
He urged parishioners to approach disagreements with charity and to recognize God’s presence even during difficult circumstances.
His farewell message concluded with a Hail Mary for the parish and a simple expression of affection for the community he has served.
“Thank you, Most Precious Blood, I love you.”
Petition Raised Concerns About Parish Leadership
The controversy surrounding Father Ciucci extends beyond disagreements about his homilies.
In 2025, parishioners organized a Change.org petition addressed to Archbishop Samuel Aquila, who preceded Golka as Denver’s archbishop.
The petition, which received 889 signatures, described concerns about the atmosphere at Most Precious Blood Church and its affiliated school.
Organizers alleged declining attendance, significant turnover among employees and ministry leaders, and deteriorating relationships between parish leadership and members of the community.
“We feel there has been a loss of ‘psychological safety’ at MPB,” the petition stated.
The organizers also alleged that some parishioners, parents, and staff feared negative consequences for raising concerns or questioning decisions made by parish leadership.
The petition characterized Ciucci’s leadership style as insufficiently collaborative and called for greater accountability.
However, the petition did not establish the causes of staff departures or independently substantiate all of the allegations it raised.
The circumstances surrounding those complaints remain important to understanding the dispute, particularly because the archdiocese has not publicly provided a detailed explanation connecting the petition to the sabbatical decision.
Traditional Catholic Preaching Becomes a Point of Contention
Some of the strongest public criticism of Father Ciucci has focused on the content and tone of his preaching.
According to The Denver Post, former parishioner David Thomas said he left Most Precious Blood and began attending Holy Family Catholic Church because Ciucci’s homilies emphasized “penance, guilt, hellfire and damnation.”
These subjects, while sometimes uncomfortable, have long been part of Catholic teaching concerning sin, judgment, repentance, and salvation.
One particularly notable example was an August 2025 homily titled “Why Hell Is Welcoming.”
During the sermon, Ciucci discussed the spiritual dangers of choosing a path away from God and contrasted the difficulty of pursuing holiness with the ease of following destructive temptations.
“The path to heaven is narrow,” he explained, emphasizing the importance of deliberately choosing a life directed toward God.
The homily reflected traditional Catholic teaching that human freedom carries moral responsibility and that salvation requires a response to God’s grace.
Another parishioner, Michelle Vogt, told The Denver Post that an Easter homily criticizing people who benefit from Church resources without contributing to the community became a turning point in her dissatisfaction with the pastor.
The precise context of those remarks remains disputed, and the available reporting does not establish whether the priest intended to criticize specific individuals or address the broader responsibility of Catholics to support their parish.
While parishioners have a legitimate interest in respectful pastoral leadership, Catholic priests are also entrusted with proclaiming Church teaching, including teachings that may challenge or unsettle their congregations.
The distinction between concerns about a priest’s leadership and objections to Catholic doctrine is therefore central to the controversy.
Archbishop Golka Faces Questions Over Clergy Decisions
Archbishop James Golka, appointed to lead the Archdiocese of Denver by Pope Leo XIV earlier in 2026, has faced additional scrutiny over another recent decision involving a prominent Catholic priest.
According to LifeSiteNews, Golka directed Father Chad Ripperger, a well-known Catholic exorcist, to refrain from public ministry for one year.
That decision prompted criticism from supporters of Ripperger, including a petition seeking intervention from the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.
The circumstances surrounding Ripperger’s restrictions are separate from those involving Father Ciucci, and the available information does not establish that the two decisions were made for the same reasons.
Nevertheless, the developments have drawn attention to the archbishop’s approach to clergy oversight and the relationship between episcopal authority and priests whose ministries emphasize traditional Catholic teachings.
A Parish Facing an Uncertain Future
For Most Precious Blood Catholic Church, Father Ciucci’s departure represents a significant transition after several years of reported tension within the parish community.
Supporters of the priest may view his departure as troubling, particularly given the criticism directed at his preaching on established Catholic moral teachings.
Others have expressed concerns about leadership, communication, and the overall atmosphere within the parish and school.
The available reports do not establish that Archbishop Golka requested the sabbatical specifically because of Ciucci’s traditional preaching. The archbishop’s complete reasoning has not been publicly detailed in the material reported.
For his part, Ciucci has chosen to emphasize forgiveness, prayer, and trust in God’s providence rather than encourage opposition to his successor.
His message reflects a central challenge facing Catholic communities: remaining faithful to the Church’s teachings while also preserving charity, unity, and mutual respect.
As Father Ciucci prepares for his sabbatical, the future of his priestly assignment remains uncertain. His final appeal to parishioners, however, was clear: look beyond the controversy, welcome their new pastor, and keep their attention fixed on Christ.
Your support brings the truth to the world.
Catholic Online News exists because of donors like you. We are 100% funded by people who believe the world deserves real, uncensored news rooted in faith and truth — not corporate agendas. Your gift ensures millions can continue to access the news they can trust — stories that defend life, faith, family, and freedom.
When truth is silenced, your support speaks louder.