In the heart of downtown Los Angeles last week, a dramatic scene unfolded that ignited public confusion, concern over federal tactics, and a renewed debate about the role of local police in immigration enforcement.
A group of armed, masked men were seen dragging a woman into an SUV in the Fashion District. Alarmed by what appeared to be a kidnapping, witnesses dialed 911. But when LAPD officers arrived, instead of arresting the men, they formed a protective line around them—prompting outcry from the gathered crowd who demanded the woman’s release.
As it turned out, the men were not kidnappers, but Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents, and the woman was a U.S. citizen.
The story took another turn when federal authorities revealed that the woman, Andrea Guadalupe Velez, had been arrested for allegedly assaulting an ICE officer during an attempted apprehension of another individual. According to federal filings, Velez “abruptly” stepped into the path of the agent “in an apparent effort to prevent him from apprehending the male subject he was chasing.” At just 4 feet 11 inches tall, Velez reportedly extended her arms in front of the agent before the two collided.
Her mother, Margarita Flores, witnessed the moment from her car. “I saw a man running toward my daughter and then she just fell to the ground,” Flores told the Los Angeles Times. Flores said she couldn’t see any form of identification on the men or their vehicles, which had no license plates. She told her other daughter to call the police, fearing her daughter was being kidnapped.
When LAPD officers arrived, Velez ran toward them. But according to her sister, Estrella Rosas, “One of the ICE agents went back after her and fully [put] her in handcuffs… He physically had to carry her to put her inside the car and they drove away in the car that had no license plates.”
Velez spent two days in a federal detention facility and was charged with assaulting a federal officer. She was released on $5,000 bail and is expected in court July 17.
The response from local police has only intensified criticism. Police Chief Jim McDonnell defended LAPD’s decision to protect the federal agents from the crowd, saying, “Their first responsibility was to keep the peace and that they had no authority to interfere with the federal operation” (Los Angeles Times, July 1, 2025). But many civic leaders and residents remain unconvinced.
Mike Bonin, former City Council member and now executive director of the Pat Brown Institute for Public Affairs at Cal State L.A., stated plainly: “What happened downtown on Tuesday morning certainly looked and felt like LAPD was supporting ICE.”
This incident was not isolated. LAPD officials confirmed they have received at least seven calls in recent weeks about what appeared to be kidnappings—only to discover they were ICE operations. In another case, masked Border Patrol agents staging near Dodger Stadium prompted a flood of social media speculation and protest. LAPD once again responded not to intervene, but to provide crowd control.
The lack of visible identification on federal agents—often masked, in unmarked vehicles, and wearing tactical gear—has fueled fears that these operations could lead to impersonations or abuses. “Allowing unidentified actors to forcibly detain individuals without oversight is not only reckless—it erodes public trust and undermines the very rule of law,” wrote City Councilmember Monica Rodriguez in a letter to the Police Commission.
Rodriguez emphasized that this approach creates an “environment ripe for abuse and impersonation,” and called on the LAPD to implement clear protocols for verifying the identities of masked federal agents.
For Catholics and people of conscience, these developments strike at deep moral questions: How do we uphold the dignity of the human person while respecting the rule of law? What role should local communities play in ensuring justice and transparency during federal enforcement actions?
The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that “the more prosperous nations are obliged, to the extent they are able, to welcome the foreigner in search of security and the means of livelihood” (CCC 2241). When agents in masks detain individuals without presenting warrants or identifying themselves clearly, it challenges not only legal standards, but also moral ones.
The confusion and fear caused by these encounters have had ripple effects. Many residents feel caught between obeying the law and protecting their neighbors. According to a recent poll by YouGov, nearly three-quarters of Californians believe local police officers should arrest federal immigration agents who “act maliciously or knowingly exceed their authority under federal law.” A majority also supported forbidding collaboration with immigration enforcement altogether and creating legal pathways to hold authorities accountable for civil rights violations.
The LAPD has attempted to ease tensions by implementing new guidelines. Officers are now required to verify the identity of federal agents and record the interaction on body-worn cameras. But some critics say these efforts fall short.
As the City Council considers motions to restrict LAPD’s involvement in federal immigration operations, the streets of L.A. remain tense. In Boyle Heights, Eastside residents marched on Tuesday, chanting during one of many “Reclaim Our Streets” demonstrations sparked by recent enforcement activity.
For Catholics and other Angelenos striving to live out the Gospel command to “welcome the stranger,” the moment demands both courage and discernment. Public safety, human dignity, and the transparency of government agencies are not mutually exclusive. But when any one of them is compromised, it becomes the responsibility of the faithful to ask uncomfortable but necessary questions—starting with this one: Are we doing enough to protect the vulnerable while holding power accountable?
—
Sources: Los Angeles Times reporting by Luke Johnson, Genaro Molina, Christina House, and statements from LAPD, ICE, and city officials.
