Religious Freedom at Risk: Majority of U.S. States Fail to Meet Key Protections in 2026 Report

praying on American Flag for religious freedom

Religious freedom remains a growing concern across the United States, with a new national report revealing that most states lack sufficient legal protections for religious organizations and faith-based nonprofits.

The 2026 Faith and Freedom Index, released November 16 by the Napa Legal Institute, found that more than half of U.S. states scored below 50% in their protections for religious liberty. The findings raise important questions about whether religious institutions can carry out their missions without facing unnecessary legal and regulatory obstacles.

For Catholic organizations, including schools, charities, and other faith-based ministries, the report highlights the importance of state laws that protect religious identity and the freedom to operate according to sincerely held beliefs.

Alabama and Kansas Lead Religious Freedom Rankings

According to the Napa Legal Institute’s 2026 findings, only two states earned scores exceeding 80% for religious freedom protections.

Alabama ranked highest nationwide with a score of 94%, followed by Kansas at 87%.

At the opposite end of the rankings, Michigan received just 24%, placing it last in the nation for the second consecutive year.

The institute identified several weaknesses in Michigan’s legal framework, including the absence of a state-level Religious Freedom Restoration Act and a lack of protections for religious exercise during declared emergencies.

Michigan’s constitution also contains a Blaine amendment, a provision restricting public funding of religious education.

Despite Alabama’s leading position, its constitution also includes a Blaine amendment, demonstrating that even states with strong overall religious freedom protections may retain legal restrictions affecting religious education.

The Napa Legal Institute nevertheless described Alabama as “one of the best places to operate a faith-based nonprofit in the United States.”

Religious Liberty Protections Cross Political Lines

One significant finding of the report is that religious freedom protections do not necessarily correspond with a state’s political affiliation.

In its announcement of the 2026 index, the Napa Legal Institute emphasized that religious freedom scores “do not neatly fall along partisan lines.”

The organization explained that some traditionally Democratic states provide stronger protections in certain areas than states typically associated with Republican leadership.

For example, New York scored higher than North Dakota in the institute’s rankings.

Similarly, Hawaii and Maine were found to offer stronger employment law protections for religious employers than South Dakota and West Virginia.

The findings suggest that protecting religious liberty requires attention to individual state laws rather than assumptions based on political leadership.

Why State Laws Matter for Catholic Organizations

The Faith and Freedom Index examines several legal factors that influence the ability of religious institutions to operate freely.

These include constitutional protections for religious exercise, employment laws affecting religious employers, and restrictions on public funding for religious education.

Such protections are particularly relevant to Catholic institutions seeking to preserve their religious mission while navigating state employment requirements, nonprofit regulations, and other legal obligations.

According to EWTN News, the index also evaluates regulatory freedom, an area in which many states received significantly higher scores than they did for religious liberty protections.

This distinction suggests that a state may provide a relatively favorable regulatory environment for nonprofit organizations while still lacking important safeguards for religious exercise.

Frank DeVito, senior counsel at the Napa Legal Institute, emphasized the need for legal systems that allow faith-based organizations to dedicate their resources to serving their communities.

“Every good state law that helps rather than hinders the work of religious organizations is a victory,” DeVito said.

He also encouraged Americans to “consider how the laws in their states burden religion when they cast their votes.”

A Continuing Challenge for Religious Freedom in America

The 2026 findings underscore the importance of protecting religious liberty at the state level, even as religious freedom remains a fundamental principle of American constitutional government.

For Catholics, religious freedom extends beyond the ability to attend Mass or practice personal devotions. It also concerns the freedom of Catholic schools, charitable organizations, and ministries to serve others while remaining faithful to their religious convictions.

The Napa Legal Institute’s report demonstrates that legal protections for those activities vary considerably across the country, regardless of political affiliation.

As states continue to shape laws affecting religious institutions, the findings offer Catholic leaders, nonprofit organizations, and voters an opportunity to examine whether existing policies adequately protect the freedom to live and serve according to faith.

The full 2026 Faith and Freedom Index is available through the Napa Legal Institute, with additional reporting provided by EWTN News.


Your support brings the truth to the world.

Catholic Online News exists because of donors like you. We are 100% funded by people who believe the world deserves real, uncensored news rooted in faith and truth — not corporate agendas. Your gift ensures millions can continue to access the news they can trust — stories that defend life, faith, family, and freedom.

When truth is silenced, your support speaks louder.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *