As President Donald Trump settles into his second term, a growing rift is emerging between him and parts of his base—this time, over the closure of the Justice Department’s review into the Jeffrey Epstein case.
In a campaign defined by vows to “demolish the deep state,” Trump’s more tempered stance on the Epstein files has sparked confusion and criticism, particularly among conservatives who expected a forceful reckoning with what they perceive as government corruption.
“We will fight for America like no one has ever fought before. 2024 is our final battle,” Trump declared on the campaign trail. “With you at my side, we will demolish the deep state,” he said in a statement quoted by NPR’s Ailsa Chang.
Yet following the Justice Department’s recent announcement that it is closing its review into Epstein’s death and related allegations, some of Trump’s most loyal supporters are voicing their dismay. The DOJ memo found no evidence that Epstein, a convicted sex offender who died by suicide in 2019, had a so-called “client list” or blackmailed powerful figures, according to NPR’s Stephen Fowler. The FBI’s findings reaffirmed previous conclusions that Epstein’s death was a suicide and that no further criminal activity involving powerful individuals could be confirmed.
Despite these official findings, Epstein’s case has long been the subject of conspiracy theories across the political spectrum. Notably, several high-profile members of Trump’s own administration have publicly expressed doubts about the official narrative. Attorney General Pam Bondi previously stated that the “Epstein client list was, quote, ‘sitting on my desk right now to review,’” while FBI Director Kash Patel and Deputy Director Dan Bongino told Fox News that Epstein’s death was in fact a suicide.
President Trump, however, seemed to try to close the door on the subject. In a post on Truth Social, he defended Bondi but urged his followers to “not waste time and energy on Jeffrey Epstein.” He even speculated, without evidence, that “the so-called files were created by Democrats to go after him,” a statement that has drawn fire from conservative commentators.
This apparent shift in tone has not gone unnoticed. At the Turning Point USA Student Action Summit in Florida, political commentator Tucker Carlson, who has long questioned the official version of Epstein’s death, expressed his frustration with the administration. “The fact that the U.S. government, the one that I voted for, refused to take my question seriously and instead said, case closed, shut up conspiracy theorist, was too much for me,” Carlson said.
The tension highlights a broader dilemma facing President Trump: balancing the demands of a coalition composed of disparate conservative factions—populists, traditionalists, libertarians, and conspiracy-leaning segments—united largely by loyalty to him.
While some within the Trump base are clearly disillusioned, it’s unclear whether this backlash will significantly affect his support. As Fowler notes, “At this point, the people that like him, like him, and the ones who don’t, don’t.”
Meanwhile, questions surrounding Epstein’s death remain of interest beyond just the MAGA movement. Democrats have also seized on the issue, with some calling for greater transparency. A recent House resolution—largely symbolic—seeks the release of “all the files related to the Epstein case.”
For Catholics observing the unfolding situation, the Epstein case remains a painful reminder of the abuse of power and the need for moral clarity and justice, especially for victims. While political factions argue over the implications, the deeper issue remains a call for integrity, transparency, and the protection of human dignity—values central to Catholic social teaching.
As investigations conclude and political discourse continues, one truth remains: the pursuit of justice should never become a partisan casualty.
Your support brings the truth to the world.
Catholic Online News exists because of donors like you. We are 100% funded by people who believe the world deserves real, uncensored news rooted in faith and truth — not corporate agendas. Your gift ensures millions can continue to access the news they can trust — stories that defend life, faith, family, and freedom.
When truth is silenced, your support speaks louder.
