Father Carlos Martins, a Detroit-based Catholic priest known for his popular podcast The Exorcist Files, is facing criminal charges after allegedly pulling out a teenage girl’s hair and using it to floss his teeth. The incident reportedly took place on November 25, 2024, during a visit to the Diocese of Joliet in Illinois.
According to a criminal complaint filed on January 22, Martins “placed hair” of a minor “in his mouth” and made “physical contact in an insulting or provoking nature” (WKRC). The alleged encounter occurred while Martins and his ministry group were on a nationwide tour showcasing the Relic of St. Jude.
A teenage boy who was waiting in line to see the relic reported to police that Martins, who is bald, made a joke about once having hair before grabbing a 13-year-old girl’s hair and putting it in his mouth. The boy also stated that Martins flossed with the girl’s hair before sitting behind her in the pew and making “growling” noises (WKRC). Following the allegations, the Diocese of Joliet released a statement confirming that Martins had been ordered to “depart from our parish and out of our Diocese.” Authorities took him into custody on January 27, and he has since denied the allegations.
Exorcism and the Role of Catholic Exorcists
Father Martins is best known for his work in exorcism ministry, a topic that has gained significant public interest through his podcast. The Catholic Church recognizes the existence of demonic possession and authorizes exorcisms in specific cases. According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC 1673), “When the Church asks publicly and authoritatively in the name of Jesus Christ that a person or object be protected against the power of the Evil One and withdrawn from his dominion, it is called exorcism.” The rite of exorcism is only performed by a designated priest, known as an exorcist, with permission from the bishop.
However, exorcists are called to act in accordance with Church teaching, emphasizing spiritual healing and respect for human dignity. The alleged actions of Martins, if proven true, stand in stark contrast to the principles guiding an exorcist’s ministry. The Church teaches that exorcisms must be conducted with great care and respect, avoiding any form of harm to individuals involved.
Legal and Ecclesiastical Consequences
While the criminal case against Martins is ongoing, the Church’s response suggests a desire to ensure accountability. The Diocese of Joliet acted swiftly by removing him from ministry within their jurisdiction, reinforcing the Church’s stance on appropriate conduct among clergy.
The case also raises broader concerns regarding the conduct of religious figures in public ministry. The Catholic Church has implemented various measures in recent years to ensure greater accountability for clergy members. This includes the establishment of policies for reporting misconduct and safeguarding minors and vulnerable individuals.
As this case develops, Catholics are reminded to pray for all involved, including the alleged victim, the accused, and the Church, that truth and justice prevail in accordance with Christ’s teachings.