In a significant shift, Disney has decided to cut a transgender storyline from its upcoming animated series Win or Lose, marking a departure from the direction initially planned for the show. The series, which will debut in 2025, is Pixar’s first long-form show and follows the lives of a co-ed middle school softball team as they prepare for a championship game. Each episode is meant to provide a unique perspective from various characters, including their insecurities, relationships with their parents, and even the experiences of a lovesick umpire.
However, a transgender storyline that was originally incorporated into the show has now been removed. This decision has drawn attention, particularly regarding the portrayal of gender identity for young audiences. A source confirmed to Variety that references to one character’s gender identity were cut from later episodes, though no full episode was dedicated to the transgender topic. The character, previously depicted as transgender, was voiced by 18-year-old trans actress Chanel Stewart.
In a statement regarding the change, a Disney spokesperson explained, “When it comes to animated content for a younger audience, we recognize that many parents would prefer to discuss certain subjects with their children on their own terms and timeline.” This acknowledgment reflects Disney’s recognition of the importance of parental discretion in addressing complex topics such as gender identity.
The decision to alter the show aligns with the ongoing discussions within society, where many parents, particularly within the Catholic community, seek to guide their children through these sensitive subjects in ways that are consistent with their beliefs and values. The Catholic Church teaches the inherent dignity of every human person, created male or female, and holds that gender is a gift from God. As such, many Catholics express concern about the promotion of transgender ideologies, especially in media targeted at impressionable audiences.
The change in Win or Lose also comes as part of a broader trend in entertainment, where parents and community groups have increasingly called for more control over the content children are exposed to. By choosing to adjust the narrative, Disney seems to be responding to the desire for content that respects parental guidance, allowing families to address such matters privately, according to their faith and beliefs.
The series is written, directed, and executive produced by Carrie Hobson and Michael Yates, with Will Forte leading the voice cast as the coach. Win or Lose is set to premiere on February 11, 2025.
While this move might reflect a shift in corporate strategy, it also highlights the growing dialogue around the role of entertainment in shaping young minds and the responsibility of creators to respect the values of families and communities.
