The Church’s Ongoing Effort to Address Abuse Allegations: A Comprehensive Look at CARA’s Latest Survey

Vatican dark

A new survey reveals the staggering financial and historical impact of sexual abuse allegations in the Catholic Church, highlighting ongoing efforts for justice and prevention.

A new survey conducted by Georgetown University’s Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA) reveals significant findings regarding the Catholic Church’s financial response to abuse allegations. The survey, which spans two decades of data collection, highlights the scale of payouts, the demographics of abuse victims, and the Church’s ongoing efforts to prevent future abuse. For Catholics who care deeply about the integrity and future of the Church, these findings serve as a stark reminder of the past and a call for continued vigilance and healing.

Financial Impact of Abuse Allegations

CARA’s recent survey has confirmed that dioceses, eparchies, and religious communities of men in the U.S. have paid out a staggering total of $5,025,346,893 related to minor abuse allegations since 2004. These payments include “settlements paid to victims, other payments to victims, support for offenders, [and] attorneys’ fees,” as well as other associated costs, according to CARA.

While these large sums of money have been paid over the last 20 years, the majority of the alleged abuse occurred decades ago. 80% of the alleged crimes took place in the 1980s or earlier. This reveals a profound historical pattern of abuse that has shaped the Church’s response to these crises. As CARA notes, “the vast majority of the alleged abuse occurred much earlier,” with only 3% of the allegations reported after 2000.

The Scope of the Allegations

CARA’s findings cover over two decades of data from about 200 dioceses and eparchies, as well as approximately 220 religious communities of men. In total, 16,276 allegations have been categorized as “credible.” These allegations were assessed by respondents, who determined them to be either “credible” or “unsubstantiated/obviously false.” The survey found that the number of credible allegations jumped by 46% in its second decade, which CARA attributes to “the greater number of large lawsuits and state investigations” as well as “temporary relaxations of statutes of limitations on crimes and lawsuits” in some states.

A key finding is the significant drop in reported allegations as the years have progressed. The survey reveals that more than 9 in 10 of all credible allegations took place before 1989. This points to the immense challenge faced by the Church during the late 20th century. More than 80% of alleged victims were male, with a substantial portion between the ages of 10 to 14 at the time of abuse. Additionally, 20% of the victims were 9 years old or younger.

Perpetrators and the Church’s Efforts for Accountability

The data also sheds light on the identity of the alleged perpetrators. According to CARA, there are 4,490 alleged perpetrators, with 95% being priests, 4% religious brothers, and 1% deacons. A staggering 86% of all alleged perpetrators have already been “deceased, removed from ministry, laicized, or are missing,” according to the survey.

It is crucial to note that the Church has been actively working to prevent further abuse and address the crisis in the decades since the abuse allegations came to light. Dioceses and religious communities have reported spending $727,994,390 on child abuse prevention efforts, averaging about $36,000,000 annually over the past 20 years. These expenditures cover a range of initiatives, including “safe environment coordinator and victim assistance coordinator salaries, tracking and other administrative expenses, training programs for adults and children, and background checks,” according to the survey.

The Church’s commitment to addressing abuse and ensuring the safety of children has only grown stronger over the years. The first decade of the survey saw $259,771,061 spent on abuse prevention, but by the second decade, the expenditure jumped by 80% to $468,223,329.

An Unprecedented Effort for Healing

In light of these findings, CARA has praised the Church’s efforts to combat the abuse crisis, stating that the U.S. Church’s initiative to address sexual abuse and to implement safeguards “is unprecedented by any nongovernmental organization and is the largest effort of its kind.” The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) first issued norms for handling the sexual abuse of minors in 2002 with the publication of the “Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People”. In this document, the bishops acknowledged the profound suffering caused by clergy abuse and the ways in which these offenses had been mishandled.

“As bishops, we have acknowledged our mistakes and our roles in that suffering, and we apologize and take responsibility again for too often failing victims and the Catholic people in the past,” the bishops wrote in the charter.

Moving Forward with Faith and Responsibility

For Catholics, these findings serve as a powerful reminder of the need for ongoing vigilance, prayer, and action to support victims and ensure that such tragedies never occur again. The U.S. Church’s commitment to both justice for victims and the prevention of future abuse remains critical as it continues to rebuild trust and restore its mission to protect and serve the faithful.

CARA’s survey provides Catholics with important data to reflect on how far the Church has come, and yet, it underscores the need for continued dedication to safeguarding children and protecting the dignity of all people. As members of the Body of Christ, it is essential that we recognize our shared responsibility in these efforts and pray for the healing of all affected by this dark chapter in the Church’s history.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *